Ranking gate
- Comparable weapon stats — damage, range or swing behavior — from any measured source.
- A documented rarity or drop model, so “how hard to get” is a number, not a vibe.
- Role-use evidence: whether the scythe or knife change round combat for murderer or sheriff.
- Documented round outcomes from reliable exact-game play, not other universes.
- A confirmed trading system and value unit, if price tiers are ever requested.
Any one of the first four unlocks a provisional ranking with its source named. Until then, this page's comparison table is the honest ceiling.
Value-list warning
Murder-mystery trading economies are universe-bound. Roblox identity is enforced per experience: this game is place 91861344866513 by Voltoz97, created June 20, 2026. An older KraKeurZZ-named game or an MM2 value list describes a different universe with different items — copying its numbers here would fabricate an economy this game has never published.
Community reception is real but separate from item value: the official API snapshot of 2026-07-17 counted 4,370 up-votes against 929 down-votes (82.5%) across 9,371,673 visits — players like the game, which is not the same as any item being “worth” something.